Madness string 84652

Random mermaid
I'll ask it again, and again, and again. A thousand times past, and a thousand times forward. Laterally seen, they're all the same question, all the same instant, and yet so many answers. Which one is true? Choose!

We've got a dead body with five holes in it and it means nothing. And now we've got a second dead body that couldn't breathe through water.